Hashem Answers Iyov from the Storm for Kids: How to Explain It
At the end of Sefer Iyov, Hashem answers Iyov from the storm with questions about creation. Here is the story, its lesson, and how to explain it to children at ages 3 to 4, 6 to 7 and 10 to 12.
Published by Torah Tale.
Create this book for your child
At the end of Sefer Iyov, Hashem answers Iyov from the storm. He does not give a reason for what Iyov went through, but asks him questions about the sea, the morning, the stars and the animals of the wild. Children connect with this because it speaks to a question every child eventually asks, and it answers with something steady: Hashem runs the whole world, and He cares for every creature in it.
What happens when Hashem answers Iyov from the storm?
Sefer Iyov is in Kesuvim. It tells of Iyov, a man the pasuk describes as whole and upright, who went through great loss and hardship. His friends came to comfort him and then argued with him about why it was happening. You can read about them in Iyov's Three Friends for Kids, and about the first test in Sefer Iyov for Kids.
Then, in chapter 38, the pasuk says that Hashem answered Iyov min hase'arah, from the storm. Hashem spoke directly to Iyov, who had been asking for an answer.
What does Hashem actually say to Iyov?
Hashem asks questions, one after another. The first is Eifoh hayisa b'yosdi aretz, 'Where were you when I founded the earth?' (38:4). Hashem goes on to ask about the boundary of the sea, about how the morning comes, about the storehouses of snow and hail, and about the rain.
Then the questions turn to living creatures, and children love this part. Who prepares food for the raven when its young cry out? Do you know when the mountain goats give birth? Who set the wild donkey free? Hashem speaks of the horse and the eagle too, and later describes two mighty creatures, the behemos and the livyasan, that no person can tame.
The questions are not meant to shame Iyov. They show him a world so full of wisdom and care that no person could have planned it, and that Hashem looks after down to its smallest details.
How does Iyov answer, and how does the story end?
Iyov answers humbly. He says he is small and has nothing to reply (40:4). Later he says, 'I know that You can do everything' (42:2).
Hashem then tells Elifaz that He is angry with him and his two friends, because they had not spoken correctly as Iyov had. Iyov davens for his friends, and the pasuk says that Hashem restored Iyov when he davened for them (42:10). Iyov's family and relatives came to him, and he had seven sons and three daughters. The pasuk says he lived another 140 years.
What is the lesson for children?
It is a lot for a young child to take in, so keep to a few simple ideas:
- Hashem takes care of everything. The raven's chicks, the mountain goats and the rain are all His, and He is with His world all the time.
- We do not always understand, and that is okay. Iyov did not get a list of reasons. He got a deeper sense of who Hashem is, and he answered with humility and emunah.
- We daven for others. Iyov davened for friends whose words had hurt him, and this is how the story turns toward its ending.
For another view of Hashem's care in creation, see Tehillim for Kids: Praising Creation.
How do I explain this to a 4-year-old, a 7-year-old and an older child?
- Ages 3 to 4: Say it in a few sentences: 'Iyov was a good man and he had a very hard time. Hashem spoke to him and reminded him how big and wonderful the world is, and that Hashem takes care of everything, even baby birds.' Skip the details of the losses.
- Ages 6 to 7: Pick two or three of the animal questions and ask them out loud. 'Who gives the raven its food?' Then tell them that Iyov understood that Hashem knows far more than we do, and that in the end Hashem made things good for him again.
- Ages 10 to 12: Talk about the idea that Hashem answered with questions and not with reasons. Ask why that might have helped Iyov more than an explanation. Mention that Hashem told the friends they had not spoken correctly, so we should be careful about telling a person who is suffering why it is happening.
If a child asks 'why do bad things happen?', it is fine to say 'I don't know why, but Hashem does, and He is with us.' If a child is going through a real loss, ask your rav or teacher how to speak with them.
What can we ask at the Shabbos table?
Reading is a lovely thing to do on Shabbos, and so is talking. Here are questions that need no pencils or screens:
- What was Iyov wondering about before Hashem answered him?
- Which of Hashem's questions about animals was your favorite?
- Why do you think Hashem asked questions instead of giving reasons?
- How did Iyov answer Hashem?
- What did Iyov do for his friends, even though their words had hurt him?
- When is a time we can say 'I don't understand, but I trust Hashem'?
What is a personalized Torah Tale book of Sefer Iyov like?
Torah Tale makes personalized Torah storybooks, and Sefer Iyov is in the Kesuvim collection. Your child's name and likeness, from one uploaded photo, appear on every page, illustrated in 3D animated-film style. Up to eight siblings can appear in one book, ages 0 to 18. The book is written with careful rabbinical guidance and strict tznius, and is reviewed by our team before it goes to print.
Every book ends with a discussion page of 10 questions that mix comprehension with middos, so the story gets talked about and not just read. If you add parents, grandparents or other relatives with their photos, they appear with the children on a closing family page, in every format.
Softcover 8″×8″
Hardcover 8″×8″
Board book 6″×6″
Coloring book 8.5″×11″
You can choose a softcover photo book 8x8 (ages 4-8), a hardcover photo book 8x8 (ages 5-18), or a board book 6x6 with rounded safety corners (ages 0-4). Softcover and hardcover books open with a dedication page. An optional matching coloring book 8.5x11 in black-and-white line art can be added. It is a weekday activity, for a weekday afternoon or erev Shabbos, and never for Shabbos or Yom Tov. The book itself is perfect for reading at the Shabbos table or on a long Yom Tov afternoon. The book is available in English, Hebrew and Yiddish.
Creating a book takes about five minutes. You make a free account and answer a few short questions: each child's name, boy or girl, age and one photo, any siblings, the story, your community (asked once), the language and the format.
Ready to give your child a Sefer Iyov book of their own? You can create the book in a few minutes.
Frequently asked questions
What does Hashem say to Iyov from the storm?
Hashem asks Iyov a long series of questions about creation, beginning with 'Where were you when I founded the earth?' (Iyov 38:4). The questions cover the sea, the morning, snow and hail, rain, the stars, and animals such as the raven, the mountain goat, the horse and the eagle. Hashem does not explain the reason for Iyov's suffering in this answer.
What is the lesson of Hashem answering Iyov from the storm?
Children can learn that Hashem's wisdom is far greater than ours and that He cares for every part of His world. We do not always understand why things happen, and we can stay humble and keep trusting Him. We also see that Iyov davened for his friends, and that Hashem restored him afterward.
How do I explain this story to a 4-year-old?
Keep it simple and gentle: Iyov was a good man who went through hard times, and Hashem spoke to him and showed him how big and wonderful the world is. Hashem takes care of everything, even the baby birds. You do not need to describe Iyov's losses in detail.
Is Sefer Iyov appropriate for children?
Yes, when it is told with care and focused on the answer from the storm and the ending. The sefer has heavy parts, so with young children it helps to leave out details of the losses. Older children can handle more of the questions, and a parent or teacher can always bring a real question to a rav.
What happens at the end of Sefer Iyov?
Hashem tells Elifaz that he and his two friends did not speak correctly, and Iyov davens for them. Then Hashem restores Iyov, his family and relatives come to him, and the pasuk says he had seven sons and three daughters. Iyov lived another 140 years.
Is there a personalized children's book about Sefer Iyov?
Yes. Torah Tale offers Sefer Iyov in its Kesuvim collection, with your child's name and likeness in 3D animated-film style on every page. Every book ends with a discussion page of 10 questions that mix comprehension with middos.